Re: Is one wu gpu better then one wu nacI/smp for research?

Moderators: Site Moderators, FAHC Science Team

Post Reply
bruce
Posts: 20910
Joined: Thu Nov 29, 2007 10:13 pm
Location: So. Cal.

Re: Is one wu gpu better then one wu nacI/smp for research?

Post by bruce »

Though you didn't mention the Android client, I'll include it in my answer.

The value to science depends on the hardware capabilities. Slower {CPUs/GPUs} with fewer threads produce less than faster [CPUs/GPUs] with more threads. As a general statement, GPUs are more powerful than CPUs which are more powerful than the processor in a typiclal phone.

The nacl client is a SMP client of sorts. I'm not sure how it establishes how many CPUs to use. The SMP client can be managed explicitly so you may be able to get more work out of the same hardware. Both of them suffer if you allocate N CPUs if, because of some other long-running process(es) only a smaller number of CPUs are available on a regular basis. GPUs generally don't have the same limitation.

At one time, the GPU client was limited to certain types of analysis whereas the CPU client was more versatile. The vsrsatility of the FAHCores for GPUs has been improved very significantly and I believe they're now equivalent.

When developing a new project, some consideration is also given to maintain a reasonable balance between projects available for client X and the resources being donated by donors running that client. Then, too, the project's due-date may be considered based on the ability of that client to complete the project on schedule.
Kjetil
Posts: 178
Joined: Sat Apr 14, 2012 5:56 pm
Location: Stavanger Norway

Re: Is one wu gpu better then one wu nacI/smp for research?

Post by Kjetil »

I had hope for yes or no? But tanks.
Nathan_P
Posts: 1180
Joined: Wed Apr 01, 2009 9:22 pm
Hardware configuration: Asus Z8NA D6C, 2 x5670@3.2 Ghz, , 12gb Ram, GTX 980ti, AX650 PSU, win 10 (daily use)

Asus Z87 WS, Xeon E3-1230L v3, 8gb ram, KFA GTX 1080, EVGA 750ti , AX760 PSU, Mint 18.2 OS

Not currently folding
Asus Z9PE- D8 WS, 2 E5-2665@2.3 Ghz, 16Gb 1.35v Ram, Ubuntu (Fold only)
Asus Z9PA, 2 Ivy 12 core, 16gb Ram, H folding appliance (fold only)
Location: Jersey, Channel islands

Re: Is one wu gpu better then one wu nacI/smp for research?

Post by Nathan_P »

I was testing some ram this afternoon so I fired up nacl on my daily driver, it used all 24 thread but only to about 70%. As for the GPU/CPU question I have to agree with Bruce, most WU are now equivalent in size and can be processed really quickly on the most powerful hardware. CPU's do have an advantage with really large WU, 1m+ atoms, but they are specialised projects and not widely used
Image
bruce
Posts: 20910
Joined: Thu Nov 29, 2007 10:13 pm
Location: So. Cal.

Re: Is one wu gpu better then one wu nacI/smp for research?

Post by bruce »

My statement is not 100% true. When the GPU core was limited to implicit solvent, it was certainly more limited, but now that both CPUs and GPUs can perform explicit solvent analyses, that different has vanished.

There probably are some differences in which force-fields can be used. Gromacs (for CPUs) and openMM (for GPUs) are not identical, but from what I understand, the differences are pretty small for the types of analysis that FAH does.
bruce
Posts: 20910
Joined: Thu Nov 29, 2007 10:13 pm
Location: So. Cal.

Re: Is one wu gpu better then one wu nacI/smp for research?

Post by bruce »

Kjetil wrote:I had hope for yes or no? But tanks.
No. :)
Kjetil
Posts: 178
Joined: Sat Apr 14, 2012 5:56 pm
Location: Stavanger Norway

Re: Is one wu gpu better then one wu nacI/smp for research?

Post by Kjetil »

Bruce: So more ppd is better for resarch then more wu, i am running 9 smp/nacI. So is better not to run nacI/smp? But more gpu? =more ppd. sorry for my bad english.

Edit okay :D
Last edited by Kjetil on Fri Apr 22, 2016 8:25 pm, edited 1 time in total.
bruce
Posts: 20910
Joined: Thu Nov 29, 2007 10:13 pm
Location: So. Cal.

Re: Re: Is one wu gpu better then one wu nacI/smp for resear

Post by bruce »

So is better not to run nacI/smp? But more gpu?
Not really.

Run both, since they're both producing good results and for the most part, they use different resources to total PPD goes up, too.
Kjetil
Posts: 178
Joined: Sat Apr 14, 2012 5:56 pm
Location: Stavanger Norway

Re: Re: Is one wu gpu better then one wu nacI/smp for resear

Post by Kjetil »

I will run gpu/naci or gpu/smp. Now i am running gpu and naci. 11 gpu and 9 nacI now at team 24.
Rel25917
Posts: 303
Joined: Wed Aug 15, 2012 2:31 am

Re: Re: Is one wu gpu better then one wu nacI/smp for resear

Post by Rel25917 »

Gpu and nacl is a bad idea. The gpu likes to have a core on the processor free and with nacl there is no way to leave one free, it always uses them all. Running them together will slow them both down.
Nathan_P
Posts: 1180
Joined: Wed Apr 01, 2009 9:22 pm
Hardware configuration: Asus Z8NA D6C, 2 x5670@3.2 Ghz, , 12gb Ram, GTX 980ti, AX650 PSU, win 10 (daily use)

Asus Z87 WS, Xeon E3-1230L v3, 8gb ram, KFA GTX 1080, EVGA 750ti , AX760 PSU, Mint 18.2 OS

Not currently folding
Asus Z9PE- D8 WS, 2 E5-2665@2.3 Ghz, 16Gb 1.35v Ram, Ubuntu (Fold only)
Asus Z9PA, 2 Ivy 12 core, 16gb Ram, H folding appliance (fold only)
Location: Jersey, Channel islands

Re: Re: Is one wu gpu better then one wu nacI/smp for resear

Post by Nathan_P »

But nacl is fixed points, no QRB so in terms of PPD it makes no major difference
Image
davidcoton
Posts: 1102
Joined: Wed Nov 05, 2008 3:19 pm
Location: Cambridge, UK

Re: Re: Is one wu gpu better then one wu nacI/smp for resear

Post by davidcoton »

GPU and NaCl on the same PC is not optimum. If the v7 client should be installed, it is easy to set up an SMP slot as well, instead of NaCl. It can be set to leave a CPU core per GPU free, and will get QRB points on both slots.

If you still run v6, unless you have a good reason, uopgrade now. :D
Image
Kjetil
Posts: 178
Joined: Sat Apr 14, 2012 5:56 pm
Location: Stavanger Norway

Re: Re: Is one wu gpu better then one wu nacI/smp for resear

Post by Kjetil »

Run process lasso? :D
Running v7 client.
PS: started folding 2004 and upgraded to v7 when it was released :mrgreen:
I miss 100-150K ppd, but more wu :D
Post Reply