GPU's for FAH

A forum for discussing FAH-related hardware choices and info on actual products (not speculation).

Moderator: Site Moderators

Forum rules
Please read the forum rules before posting.
Post Reply
Ricorocks
Posts: 475
Joined: Thu Aug 04, 2016 1:49 pm
Location: Georgetown, Texas

GPU's for FAH

Post by Ricorocks »

Looking at Amazon or others from same mfg:

A evga1070 can range from $400 - 450, all the same GTX1070!

What's important for FAH, hate to waste $50 only to find FAH can't use it.

What's important & what's not in choosing a GPU for strictly FAH
JimboPalmer
Posts: 2573
Joined: Mon Feb 16, 2009 4:12 am
Location: Greenwood MS USA

Re: GPU's for FAH

Post by JimboPalmer »

This is my understanding, others will cheerfully chime in to correct me!
Included free games will not speed up folding. :-)
Currently all WUs fit in any reasonable amount of memory, while certainly this will grow, it does not appear that spending extra for more memory is worthwhile.
It also seems true that faster memory does not have much effect on PPD, I would not spend extra for some rare memory technology.
The number and speed of shaders seems the dominant factor in folding speed within a family. (You can compare Nvidia Pascal class chips to each other but not to the earlier Maxwell chips, nor to AMDs chips) Unless Nvidia messes with our heads, all GTX 1070 will have the same number of shaders, only the speed varies.

Odd cooling technology will not help 95% of us, but if your case runs hot, you may wish to spend cash on water cooling, or remote cooling.
Tsar of all the Rushers
I tried to remain childlike, all I achieved was childish.
A friend to those who want no friends
Sn1ken
Posts: 60
Joined: Tue Feb 11, 2014 12:58 pm

Re: GPU's for FAH

Post by Sn1ken »

If you choose the cheapest 1070 vs the most expensive you will end up about the same PPD if your case do not run past 80 degrees F. In addition to this you need a minimum of CPU 3,4Ghz and PCIe 2.0 x8 to take full benefit of the GPU. PPD about 600 - 700k
Last edited by bruce on Mon Dec 12, 2016 6:25 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Reason: Added the "F" to specify that 80° is in Fahrenheit
Image
Ricorocks
Posts: 475
Joined: Thu Aug 04, 2016 1:49 pm
Location: Georgetown, Texas

Re: GPU's for FAH

Post by Ricorocks »

80 degrees refers to what? How does lesser than 3.4Ghz cpu, not take full advantage of the GPU? Requirements listed for the 1070, do not mention cpu, but want 8ghz mem, also pcie x16.

I'm curious as to how the cpu (lesser than 3.4), slows the gpu.

I have a dual 960, 1060 machine, found the right combo of fans, to keep the heat down, would the 1070, put out that much more heat, that fans won't do the job. Water cooling is a deal breaker, what's remote cooling?

Thanks
JimboPalmer
Posts: 2573
Joined: Mon Feb 16, 2009 4:12 am
Location: Greenwood MS USA

Re: GPU's for FAH

Post by JimboPalmer »

Many programs can report CPU, Drive and case temperatures. In Windows, I use Speccy, but many exist http://filehippo.com/download_speccy/

This example uses remote cooling amazon.com/dp/B01MA0YHN
Tsar of all the Rushers
I tried to remain childlike, all I achieved was childish.
A friend to those who want no friends
Ricorocks
Posts: 475
Joined: Thu Aug 04, 2016 1:49 pm
Location: Georgetown, Texas

Re: GPU's for FAH

Post by Ricorocks »

I have speccy, I see OS, cpu, ram, mb, gpu, storage, optical drive, & audio. The 80 degrees, refers to????? Is this referring to CPU or GPU? "if your case do not run past 80 degrees."

amazon.com/dp/B01MA0YHN I get 'Sorry Can't Find That Page'
foldy
Posts: 2061
Joined: Sat Dec 01, 2012 3:43 pm
Hardware configuration: Folding@Home Client 7.6.13 (1 GPU slots)
Windows 7 64bit
Intel Core i5 2500k@4Ghz
Nvidia gtx 1080ti driver 441

Re: GPU's for FAH

Post by foldy »

The GPUs with dual fan run more silent then single fan. The 80 degree must be the GPU, if it gets too hot then it will down clock its boost and so run slower and get less PPD. Some case fans help as you know ;-)
Ricorocks
Posts: 475
Joined: Thu Aug 04, 2016 1:49 pm
Location: Georgetown, Texas

Re: GPU's for FAH

Post by Ricorocks »

More CFM's = More noise = More Cooling! The 1070 per NVIDIA say's not to exceed 94 degrees. What was confusing was the term, "if your case do not run past 80 degrees." That comment implies, the air surrounding the hardware, which is not directly measured. So, do you dangle a probe inside the case & monitor, so as not to exceed 80 degrees?

What's still confusing, is the minimum 3.4Ghz cpu, so as to take full advantage of the GPU; I'm new to this & would like to understand more thoroughly! My current understanding is a cheap machine, perhaps less than 3.4Ghz cpu, increase the CFM of, of the cheap PC's fans, & get a GPU.

Foldy - Thanks, for the earlier clarification regarding, which way to go on 'folding' bang for the buck! Also on that same issue Thanks Nathan!
Nathan_P
Posts: 1180
Joined: Wed Apr 01, 2009 9:22 pm
Hardware configuration: Asus Z8NA D6C, 2 x5670@3.2 Ghz, , 12gb Ram, GTX 980ti, AX650 PSU, win 10 (daily use)

Asus Z87 WS, Xeon E3-1230L v3, 8gb ram, KFA GTX 1080, EVGA 750ti , AX760 PSU, Mint 18.2 OS

Not currently folding
Asus Z9PE- D8 WS, 2 E5-2665@2.3 Ghz, 16Gb 1.35v Ram, Ubuntu (Fold only)
Asus Z9PA, 2 Ivy 12 core, 16gb Ram, H folding appliance (fold only)
Location: Jersey, Channel islands

Re: GPU's for FAH

Post by Nathan_P »

Sn1ken wrote:If you choose the cheapest 1070 vs the most expensive you will end up about the same PPD if your case do not run past 80 degrees. In addition to this you need a minimum of CPU 3,4Ghz and PCIe 2.0 x8 to take full benefit of the GPU. PPD about 600 - 700k
The CPU part is not true, I run a 1070 and 1080 on a xeon E3-1230L, max all core turbo boost is 2.4 and I see no ppd hit at all compared to the 3.2ghz from my x5670's
Image
foldy
Posts: 2061
Joined: Sat Dec 01, 2012 3:43 pm
Hardware configuration: Folding@Home Client 7.6.13 (1 GPU slots)
Windows 7 64bit
Intel Core i5 2500k@4Ghz
Nvidia gtx 1080ti driver 441

Re: GPU's for FAH

Post by foldy »

Maybe the CPU 3,4 Ghz was meant for old single core CPUs, modern dual or quad core cpus are faster even with lower 2.4 Ghz clock speed.
Ricorocks
Posts: 475
Joined: Thu Aug 04, 2016 1:49 pm
Location: Georgetown, Texas

Re: GPU's for FAH

Post by Ricorocks »

Thanks! Messrs Foldy, Nathan! Now back to the hunt for a cheap PC & spruce it up, got a couple of potential deals, in the fire. This can become a little addictive.

All
Merry Christmas
bruce
Posts: 20910
Joined: Thu Nov 29, 2007 10:13 pm
Location: So. Cal.

Re: GPU's for FAH

Post by bruce »

foldy wrote:Maybe the CPU 3,4 Ghz was meant for old single core CPUs, modern dual or quad core cpus are faster even with lower 2.4 Ghz clock speed.
Not really accurate.

Software that is written to take advantage of multiple threads in a single CPU (such a FAHCore_a4, _a7) can accomplish more processing per unit time. A 4-threaded CPU at 2.4 GHz can complete several (less than 4) times as much work as a single-threaded CPU at 2.4 GHz. Software which is written as a single-threaded application can still use only one of the threads at a time and one thread of a 3.4 GHz processor will potentially get more work done than a single thread of a 2.4 GHz processor.

The task assigned to the CPU when you're using FAHCore_18, _21 is a single-threaded application since it's job is to move data to/from the CPU, relying on the GPUs capability to perform hundreds/thousands of FLOPs in parallel. In this case, the amount of work the CPU can accomplish on a GPU WU is limited primary by the speed of the PCIe bus, not by the characteristics of the CPU.

The general recommendation for CPUs provided you're only considering GPU folding[/u] is that there's no reason to have a fast CPU. If you're going to fold on your CPU then the speed and the number of threads supported by the CPU absolutely does matter.
FldngForGrandparents
Posts: 70
Joined: Sun Feb 28, 2016 10:06 pm

Re: GPU's for FAH

Post by FldngForGrandparents »

Zotac NVIDIA GeForce GTX 1070 AMP Extreme (ZT-P10700B-10P) at Amazon for $420 is the best bang for the buck. Can easily be overclocked to 2100Ghz. Which based on my current 1070 will do around 750k PPD+ depending on project.
Image

Dedicated to my grandparents who have passed away from Alzheimer's

Dedicated folding rig on Linux Mint 19.1:
2 - GTX 980 OC +200
1 - GTX 980 Ti OC +20
4 - GTX 1070 FE OC +200
3 - GTX 1080 OC +140
1 - GTX 1080Ti OC +120
Ricky
Posts: 483
Joined: Sat Aug 01, 2015 1:34 am
Hardware configuration: 1. 2 each E5-2630 V3 processors, 64 GB RAM, GTX980SC GPU, and GTX980 GPU running on windows 8.1 operating system.
2. I7-6950X V3 processor, 32 GB RAM, 1 GTX980tiFTW, and 2 each GTX1080FTW GPUs running on windows 8.1 operating system.
Location: New Mexico

Re: GPU's for FAH

Post by Ricky »

Ricorocks,

EVGA has different speed grades on their GPUs. There is the standard speed which has no suffix. There is the SC suffix for 'supper clocked'. There is the FTW for 'for the win'. then there can be kingpin and classified. Look at the clock specs, they are different.
Post Reply